To Our Investors and Friends,
The trend that began the year, energy stocks up and technology down, continued for May. At this point, many energy companies have posted gains between 70% to 90% year-to-date while technology companies have contracted 30% to 50% since the start of the year. Oil is the primary driver of these trends, advancing an additional 10% in May to close at $115 a barrel. Fearing recession, the 10-year Treasury bond is now moderating and fell four basis points in the month ending at 2.85%. Short-term rates fell even more, leading to a widening between the two and 10-year to 32 basis points from 19 basis points a month ago. Commodity-heavy value indexes rebounded, while technology-heavy growth indexes declined. The Bloomberg 1000 Value Index expanded 3.2%, the Bloomberg 2000 Value Index rebounded 2.2%, while the Bloomberg 1000 Growth Index declined 2.5% and the Bloomberg 2000 Growth Index dropped 2.2%.
After a brutal sell-off in growth stocks this year, we decided to examine both the math (return calculations) and the science (human reaction to stocks) of two prominent companies that we believe are representative of what is going on in the market. In the following example, we used Alphabet (GOOGL) as our growth proxy and Pepsi (PEP) as our safety proxy. As seen in the chart, GOOGL has grown its revenue at an average rate of 23% over the last decade while growing its earnings at a 23% rate over the same time frame. This is far more robust than safety holding Pepsi, that on average, grew revenue by 2% and earnings by 5% over the same time frame. Until this year, the market has paid up for this growth, as the average premium investors have been willing to pay for GOOGL’s higher growth has been about 30% (PE of 30 vs Pepsi’s PE of 23). Investors have been rewarded for the risk they were taking… from December 31, 2012, until December 31, 2021, GOOGL has appreciated 719% vs PEP’s more modest 154% appreciation over the same timeframe.
This long history of paying up for growth has undergone a material change this year. GOOGL’s 21.5% year-to-date decline has reduced its multiple to 22 times current earnings and can be compared to PEP’s 3.4% year-to-date decline that has reduced its multiple to 27 times current earnings.
Why is the market now willing to pay a 23% premium for subpar growth out of PEP? We think the answer has to do with human behavior and place significant blame on the feeling of dread investors experience when constantly checking their portfolios. In fact, 50,000 years of evolution was not enough time to turn the human mind from prey to predator, and it is obvious in how we respond to perceived threats (such as shrinking retirement accounts). Investors en masse have sold technology stocks this year without regard for the growth, profitability or cash return profile of what was being sold, and paid steep premiums for safety. We think this shift from growth into safety is overdone and expect a significant recovery in growth stocks once the fear of inflation, the Federal Reserve rate increases and the recession dissipate. We promise… investors are not at risk of being eaten by predators but are certainly at risk of having their pockets picked by savvy, patient investors.
Kingsland Investments focuses on powerful long-term trends and the businesses and management that drive them to help discover new market leaders. Although these companies may be briefly out of favor at times, we believe strong, sustainable growth could lead investors back to them. After the last few months, growth is trading at an unusually attractive level. We think now is a good time to consider investing in these emerging technology leaders.
All the best to you,
Arthur K. Weise, CFA
*Effective January 12, 2022, the Kingsland Growth Advisors name changed to Kingsland Investments. The views expressed are those of Kingsland Investments as of June 1, 2022 and are not intended as investment advice or recommendation. For informational purposes only. Investments are subject to market risk, including the loss of principal. Past performance does not guarantee future results. The stocks mentioned are for illustrative purposes only and are not a recommendation to buy or sell. There can be no assurances that any of the trends described herein will continue or will not reverse. Past events and trends do not imply, predict, or guarantee, and are not necessarily indicative of future events or results. Investors cannot invest directly in an index.